# Gem: HireAIScore fact sheet

URL: https://www.hireaiscore.com/vendors/gem
Fact sheet: https://www.hireaiscore.com/vendors/gem/facts.md
Last reviewed: 2026-11-14
Rubric: v1.0 (https://www.hireaiscore.com/methodology)

> HireAIScore rates Gem 55 out of 100 (grade F, Substantial gaps) under rubric v1.0, last reviewed November 14, 2026. Gem ranks 18 of 86 vendors rated in Candidate sourcing AI, against a category average of 46. That score is drawn from 21 evidence items across 7 rubric criteria - 19 with a cited source, 2 recording that nothing was located.

This file is the text of the profile at the URL above, for AI assistants and other software. Scores are an editorial assessment of public evidence against a published rubric. They are not legal advice, a certification, or a statement that a product is or is not compliant.

## Score

- Overall: 55/100, grade F (Substantial gaps)
- Rank: 18 of 86 in Candidate sourcing AI (category average 46)

## Criterion scores and evidence

### Article 11 Technical Documentation: 58/100 (weight 20%)

- Documentation (captured 2026-06-07): Gem's public AI Legal, Privacy & Compliance FAQ documents the models used (pre-trained Azure OpenAI), PII redaction, training-data handling, and explainability for its AI features. Source: https://help.gem.com/external/gem-ai-legal-privacy-compliance-faqs
- Audit report (captured 2026-06-07): The published BABL audit includes a System Description of Gem's AI Ranking (LLM scoring resumes 0-100% on recruiter-defined criteria) functioning as partial technical documentation. Source: https://cdn.prod.website-files.com/6257adef93867e50d84d30e2/68f7e9f45df9e76e88a93b16_BABL%20x%20Gem%202024.pdf
- Searched, not found (captured 2026-06-07): No formal model/system card, ISO 42001 certification, or instructions-for-use technical pack was found on gem.com, the trust center, or help/support sites.

### Bias Audit Transparency: 66/100 (weight 18%)

- Audit report (captured 2026-06-07): Full 22-page BABL AI Inc. bias audit of Gem's AI Ranking for NYC Local Law 144, dated 11/12/2024, with an overall PASS, scoring-rate/impact-ratio tables, and a named accountable party (Gem AI Governance Group). Source: https://cdn.prod.website-files.com/6257adef93867e50d84d30e2/68f7e9f45df9e76e88a93b16_BABL%20x%20Gem%202024.pdf
- Public statement (captured 2026-06-07): Gem states it conducted a successful bias audit with BABL for AI-powered Application Review and commits to annual audits going forward. Source: https://help.gem.com/external/gem-ai-legal-privacy-compliance-faqs
- Documentation (captured 2026-06-07): The AI Application Review product page references the third-party BABL bias audit and annual audit commitment. Source: https://www.gem.com/product/ai-powered-application-review

### FRIA Support: 35/100 (weight 15%)

- Public statement (captured 2026-06-07): Gem says it proactively monitors the EU AI Act and Colorado AI Act and commits to partner with customers to support compliance, but offers no FRIA template. Source: https://help.gem.com/external/gem-ai-legal-privacy-compliance-faqs
- Documentation (captured 2026-06-07): Gem offers a GDPR data processing addendum (DPA) and configurable retention, partial deployer-supporting material, but no fundamental-rights impact assessment guidance. Source: https://www.gem.com/compliance/security
- Searched, not found (captured 2026-06-07): No EU AI Act Article 27 Fundamental Rights Impact Assessment template or deployer-obligation guidance was found on gem.com, the trust center, or help/support pages.

### Data Governance Disclosure: 57/100 (weight 15%)

- Documentation (captured 2026-06-07): Gem discloses it does not use customer data to train AI, uses pre-trained Azure OpenAI models that do not retain customer data, and redacts PII (names, locations, LinkedIn handles) before AI processing. Source: https://help.gem.com/external/gem-ai-legal-privacy-compliance-faqs
- Documentation (captured 2026-06-07): Security page details AES-256 at rest, TLS in transit, DPA, data deletion on termination, and infrastructure ISO 27001/27017/27018, SOC 1/2/3, and PCI DSS Level 1. Source: https://www.gem.com/compliance/security
- Audit report (captured 2026-06-07): Gem holds a SOC 2 Type II report (Barr Advisory, via Vanta) covering security, availability, processing integrity, confidentiality, and privacy. Source: https://www.gem.com/blog/gem-receives-soc-2-type-ii-certification

### Human Oversight Design: 61/100 (weight 12%)

- Documentation (captured 2026-06-07): AI Application Review shows match-score summaries explaining which search criteria matched, warns against biased inputs per EEO guidelines, flags subjective criteria, and keeps advance/reject actions with recruiters. Source: https://www.gem.com/product/ai-powered-application-review
- Documentation (captured 2026-06-07): FAQ states Gem AI does not make hiring decisions, recruiters define and approve all scoring criteria and retain exclusive authority, and scoring includes percentage matches with per-criterion explanations. Source: https://help.gem.com/external/gem-ai-legal-privacy-compliance-faqs
- Audit report (captured 2026-06-07): The BABL audit documents a governance structure (Gem AI Governance Group, Legal/Compliance owner) accountable for disparate-impact risk with influence over product changes. Source: https://cdn.prod.website-files.com/6257adef93867e50d84d30e2/68f7e9f45df9e76e88a93b16_BABL%20x%20Gem%202024.pdf

### Post-Market Monitoring: 47/100 (weight 12%)

- Documentation (captured 2026-06-07): Public Gem status page shows real-time component status, uptime percentages, incident/maintenance history, and email/SMS/Slack/RSS subscription options. Source: https://status.gem.com/
- Documentation (captured 2026-06-07): Gem states it undergoes annual third-party security audits (NCC Group) and regular network/application vulnerability scans against WASC/OWASP standards. Source: https://www.gem.com/compliance/security
- Public statement (captured 2026-06-07): Gem commits to annual bias audits going forward, indicating ongoing post-deployment monitoring of its AI ranking for bias. Source: https://help.gem.com/external/gem-ai-legal-privacy-compliance-faqs

### Customer Documentation: 62/100 (weight 8%)

- Documentation (captured 2026-06-07): A dedicated, public AI Legal, Privacy & Compliance FAQ addresses AEDT/LL 144 stance, EU AI Act and Colorado monitoring, bias audit, training data, retention, PII redaction, and explainability. Source: https://help.gem.com/external/gem-ai-legal-privacy-compliance-faqs
- Documentation (captured 2026-06-07): Gem maintains public Security, Privacy, OFCCP compliance, and Terms pages plus a Trust Center (trust.gem.com) and offers a GDPR DPA. Source: https://www.gem.com/compliance/security
- Documentation (captured 2026-06-07): Detailed public product pages describe the AI Application Review and broader recruiting AI features, including compliance and bias-audit references. Source: https://www.gem.com/product/ai-powered-application-review

## Company facts

- Website: https://www.gem.com/
- Legal name: Gem Software, Inc.
- Founded: 2017
- Headquarters: United States (US)
- Pricing tier: High
- Market side: Employer-side (AEDT)
- Categories: Candidate sourcing AI, ATS-integrated AI, Screening AI, Scheduling AI
- Description: Gem is an AI-first recruiting platform combining a talent CRM, AI sourcing and outreach automation, candidate engagement, and a newer applicant tracking system with AI-powered application review and ranking.

These are company details, not findings, and carry no weight in the score.

## Head-to-head comparisons

- [Gem vs Rippling](https://www.hireaiscore.com/compare/gem-vs-rippling): 55 vs 56
- [Gem vs Ashby](https://www.hireaiscore.com/compare/ashby-vs-gem): 55 vs 56
- [Gem vs Cornerstone OnDemand](https://www.hireaiscore.com/compare/cornerstone-vs-gem): 55 vs 56
- [Gem vs iCIMS](https://www.hireaiscore.com/compare/gem-vs-icims): 55 vs 55
- [Gem vs Bullhorn](https://www.hireaiscore.com/compare/bullhorn-vs-gem): 55 vs 54
- [Gem vs SEEK](https://www.hireaiscore.com/compare/gem-vs-seek): 55 vs 54

## Conflicts of interest

No vendor pays for placement, scoring, or removal. Casework - the consulting firm that operates this directory - provides paid services to some vendors. Any active or recent (within 24 months) commercial relationship is disclosed on the affected vendor profile and the review is reassigned to an independent reviewer.

Casework has no commercial relationship with this vendor.

Full policy: https://www.hireaiscore.com/about

## How to cite

HireAIScore, "Gem" profile, rubric v1.0, last reviewed 2026-11-14. https://www.hireaiscore.com/vendors/gem

Please link the profile URL rather than this file, quote the score with its rubric version and review date, and include the vendor's reply where one is published.
