# Handshake: HireAIScore fact sheet

URL: https://www.hireaiscore.com/vendors/handshake
Fact sheet: https://www.hireaiscore.com/vendors/handshake/facts.md
Last reviewed: 2026-09-25
Rubric: v1.0 (https://www.hireaiscore.com/methodology)

> HireAIScore rates Handshake 50 out of 100 (grade F, Substantial gaps) under rubric v1.0, last reviewed September 25, 2026. Handshake ranks 48 of 160 vendors rated in Screening AI, against a category average of 46. That score is drawn from 34 evidence items across 7 rubric criteria - 27 with a cited source, 7 recording that nothing was located.

This file is the text of the profile at the URL above, for AI assistants and other software. Scores are an editorial assessment of public evidence against a published rubric. They are not legal advice, a certification, or a statement that a product is or is not compliant.

## Score

- Overall: 50/100, grade F (Substantial gaps)
- Rank: 48 of 160 in Screening AI (category average 46)

## Criterion scores and evidence

### Article 11 Technical Documentation: 48/100 (weight 20%)

- Documentation (captured 2026-09-25): The help-centre page lists each employer-side AI feature (job-form autofill, AI-drafted messages, audience selection, Job Matches and Talent List sorting, Pro applicant ranking) with its trigger, the employer's controls and the data it uses, plus governance principles such as keeping a human in the loop and internal model oversight. Source: https://support.joinhandshake.com/hc/en-us/articles/34209924173207-About-AI-Powered-Features-in-Handshake-for-Employers
- Documentation (captured 2026-09-25): This article explains how ranking works: criteria are generated from the job post, employers can use up to 10 of them (GPA, major, graduation year, location, AI-inferred skills or free text), starred criteria carry more weight, and applicants who meet many criteria go into a Recommended group. Source: https://support.joinhandshake.com/hc/en-us/articles/34820105787415-Setting-up-Candidate-Criteria-for-AI-Applicant-Ranking
- Audit report (captured 2026-09-25): Holistic AI's public LL 144 summary describes the AEDT but notes that the materials given to the auditor disclosed no model architecture, training data or performance metrics. Source: https://trust.app.holisticai.io/public/nyc-bias-audit/org_01KMR76X690BA3Y9WMNZE4FX7W/9f522451-80d4-43eb-b38e-7a9622ead8f0
- Documentation (captured 2026-09-25): The Wolfia trust portal has an AI Features page that summarises the same features and links to the help article, but none of its roughly 40 documents or 10 badges is a model card, AI technical documentation or ISO 42001. Source: https://trust.joinhandshake.com/
- Searched, not found (captured 2026-09-25): No model or system card, instructions for use, Annex IV-style technical pack, explainability statement, or reference to NIST AI RMF, ISO 42001 or the EU AI Act turned up in help-centre searches (AI, bias, fairness, EEOC, automated employment decision, AI Act), the trust portal, the joinhandshake.com legal pages or the sitemap.

### Bias Audit Transparency: 52/100 (weight 18%)

- Audit report (captured 2026-09-25): The public Holistic AI NYC LL 144 summary for AI Applicant Management (distribution date 15 Sep 2025, audit expiration date 17 Sep 2026) shows standalone and intersectional impact ratios by sex and six race/ethnicity groups, with the lowest at 0.95 standalone and about 0.92 intersectional (Asian men), and offers no downloadable report. Source: https://trust.app.holisticai.io/public/nyc-bias-audit/org_01KMR76X690BA3Y9WMNZE4FX7W/9f522451-80d4-43eb-b38e-7a9622ead8f0
- Audit report (captured 2026-09-25): The summary's data section says test data was used because no historical data with demographics was available: 3,600 synthetic CVs built from professionals' resumes in construction, finance and healthcare, each differing only by an injected sex and race label, were scored three times (10,800 scores), and a follow-up audit on real data is recommended. Source: https://trust.app.holisticai.io/public/nyc-bias-audit/org_01KMR76X690BA3Y9WMNZE4FX7W/9f522451-80d4-43eb-b38e-7a9622ead8f0
- Documentation (captured 2026-09-25): Handshake says it runs independent AI bias audits where appropriate and links the Holistic AI page as its latest summary of results. Source: https://support.joinhandshake.com/hc/en-us/articles/34209924173207-About-AI-Powered-Features-in-Handshake-for-Employers
- Documentation (captured 2026-09-25): Applicant review was relaunched on Hiring Intelligence for all paid employers on 31 Jul 2026, after the audited version's distribution date, and no audit summary covering the relaunched system has been published. Source: https://updates.joinhandshake.com/announcements/handshake-employer-product-updates-august-28-2026
- Documentation (captured 2026-09-25): The trust portal lists NYC LL 144 as a public compliance document, but its link points to a legacy Holistic AI address that redirected to a login page when opened on 25 Sep 2026. Source: https://trust.joinhandshake.com/
- Searched, not found (captured 2026-09-25): The help centre, trust portal, changelog and blog contain no fairness testing of employer-selectable criteria such as GPA, major or graduation year, and no audit of Hiring Intelligence sourcing, automated outreach or promotions targeting.

### FRIA Support: 30/100 (weight 15%)

- Searched, not found (captured 2026-09-25): No EU AI Act, Article 26 deployer-duty or Article 27 FRIA material turned up in the help centre, the trust portal (AI Features page and document list), the legal pages (Access Terms, privacy policy, DPF notice) or the sitemap.
- Documentation (captured 2026-09-25): The privacy policy names Handshake Europe GmbH (Berlin) and Handshake International UK Ltd as the company's EU and UK representatives, which shows it processes data of EU and UK users. Source: https://joinhandshake.com/privacy-policy/
- Documentation (captured 2026-09-25): The Handshake Access Terms (updated 20 Apr 2026) make the employer responsible for human oversight and for ensuring decisions made with the AI features comply with AI and data-protection law, which splits responsibility but gives the deployer no guidance. Source: https://joinhandshake.com/legal/msa/
- Documentation (captured 2026-09-25): The only AI compliance guidance for deployers is US-focused (writing EEOC-aligned criteria) and does not address fundamental-rights impacts. Source: https://support.joinhandshake.com/hc/en-us/articles/34439262238871-Guidelines-for-Writing-Smart-Compliant-AI-Matching-Criteria

### Data Governance Disclosure: 57/100 (weight 15%)

- Documentation (captured 2026-09-25): The help article states that Job Matches, Talent List and applicant ranking use employer and job details plus candidates' interest and activity patterns, that protected categories such as race or gender are not used for relevance, that audience-selection data is pseudonymised, and that employer data is not shared with third parties for AI training. Source: https://support.joinhandshake.com/hc/en-us/articles/34209924173207-About-AI-Powered-Features-in-Handshake-for-Employers
- Documentation (captured 2026-09-25): The privacy policy (updated 3 Jul 2026) cites legitimate interests as the basis for AI-assisted features that use profile data, application materials and activity data, says resumes and screening answers are sent to third-party AI providers, and excludes private profiles from employer sourcing. Source: https://joinhandshake.com/privacy-policy/
- Documentation (captured 2026-09-25): The trust portal lists 21 subprocessors with their purposes, including Anthropic, OpenAI and Google Gemini for AI workflows and Arize AI for model observability, along with SOC 2 Type II, CSA STAR Level 1 and Data Privacy Framework certifications; the SOC 2 report and data-retention policy are access-gated. Source: https://trust.joinhandshake.com/
- Documentation (captured 2026-09-25): The Spring 2026 release says Hiring Intelligence matches candidates on skills, interests and engagement behaviour across hundreds of signals, learns from employers' thumbs-up/down feedback, and favours candidates likely to engage. Source: https://joinhandshake.com/blog/employers/product-release-employers-spring-2026/
- Searched, not found (captured 2026-09-25): No description of the ranking or matching models' training data, no analysis of proxy inputs such as GPA, school, graduation year or location, and no ISO 27001 or ISO 42001 listing was found.

### Human Oversight Design: 58/100 (weight 12%)

- Documentation (captured 2026-09-25): Pro recruiters keep 3 to 10 criteria per job, star the ones that matter most and can edit them. Handshake rejects criteria it judges discriminatory, subjective or containing personal data, and recommended applicants get an AI summary and highlighted traits that explain the match. Source: https://support.joinhandshake.com/hc/en-us/articles/34820105787415-Setting-up-Candidate-Criteria-for-AI-Applicant-Ranking
- Public statement (captured 2026-09-25): Handshake says it never makes hiring decisions for employers and keeps a human in the loop, and that employers can sort applicants by application date or name instead of the AI ranking. Source: https://support.joinhandshake.com/hc/en-us/articles/34209924173207-About-AI-Powered-Features-in-Handshake-for-Employers
- Documentation (captured 2026-09-25): Hiring Intelligence sourcing generates must-haves, nice-to-haves and criteria to avoid (used to screen candidates out) from the job post, and recruiters change them through free-text requests and refine matches by shortlisting or removing candidates. Source: https://support.joinhandshake.com/hc/en-us/articles/41268176962967-How-to-Source-Candidates
- Documentation (captured 2026-09-25): Once launched, automated outreach sends AI-personalised messages on the employer's behalf every weekday to candidates who match the AI-generated criteria, until the employer stops it or the run ends. Source: https://support.joinhandshake.com/hc/en-us/articles/15109901361815-Set-Up-Automated-Job-Outreach
- Searched, not found (captured 2026-09-25): No audit logs, per-jurisdiction settings (for example, for NYC), tooling for candidate AI notices or opt-outs, or route for candidates to contest a ranking is documented.

### Post-Market Monitoring: 48/100 (weight 12%)

- Documentation (captured 2026-09-25): The Atlassian Statuspage has 11 components split between the US and UK/EU (students, EDU partners, employers, importer, reporting, plus the separate Handshake AI business) and a public incident history going back to 2021, but no postmortems and no component for ranking or matching. Source: https://status.joinhandshake.com/
- Documentation (captured 2026-09-25): A public LaunchNotes changelog, with dated employer updates back to 2023, records AI feature launches such as AI applicant management (8 Sep 2025) and Hiring Intelligence applicant review (31 Jul 2026), but only at the product level. Source: https://updates.joinhandshake.com/
- Documentation (captured 2026-09-25): The trust portal names Arize AI as a subprocessor for model observability on AI recommendations and offers a security@ route for vulnerability reports, while its incident-response, logging and monitoring, and responsible-disclosure policies are gated. Source: https://trust.joinhandshake.com/
- Searched, not found (captured 2026-09-25): No public dashboard for AI performance or bias, no model-version notes and no channel for reporting AI harms or contesting outcomes was found on the help centre, trust portal, status page or changelog.

### Customer Documentation: 60/100 (weight 8%)

- Documentation (captured 2026-09-25): This guidance on writing EEOC-aligned AI matching criteria gives employers examples of what to use and avoid (no age, birthplace or culture-fit criteria) and reminds them that anti-discrimination law applies, but it never mentions GPA. Source: https://support.joinhandshake.com/hc/en-us/articles/34439262238871-Guidelines-for-Writing-Smart-Compliant-AI-Matching-Criteria
- Documentation (captured 2026-09-25): The Colorado Job Application Fairness Act resource tells employers to avoid school-year or graduation-date qualifications, but the AI-criteria guidance does not carry this over and offers a graduation-date cutoff as a compliant example. Source: https://support.joinhandshake.com/hc/en-us/articles/24341901867159-Understanding-Colorado-s-Job-Application-Fairness-Act-A-Resource-for-Colorado-Employers-on-Handshake
- Documentation (captured 2026-09-25): The August 2026 release notes explain Hiring Intelligence, automated outreach and applicant management, list which plans get each, and state that employers make every hiring call. Source: https://joinhandshake.com/blog/employers/product-release-employers-bts-2026/
- Documentation (captured 2026-09-25): The student-facing AI explainer covers job recommendations and resume tools but does not tell job seekers that employers may rank or source them with AI. Source: https://support.joinhandshake.com/hc/en-us/articles/38856960612631-About-AI-powered-features-in-Handshake-for-students
- Searched, not found (captured 2026-09-25): No public DPA and no NYC LL 144, Illinois, California or EU AI Act guidance or candidate-notice template for employers was found, and the legal hub lists only the terms of service, Access Terms, privacy, cookie and DPF notices.

## Company facts

- Website: https://joinhandshake.com
- Legal name: Stryder Corp.
- Founded: 2014
- Headquarters: United States (US)
- Pricing tier: Mid
- Market side: Employer-side (AEDT)
- Categories: Screening AI, Candidate sourcing AI
- Description: Handshake is an early-career recruiting network whose employer tools use AI to rank applicants against employer-set criteria, find and message matching students and graduates, and target job promotions.

These are company details, not findings, and carry no weight in the score.

## Head-to-head comparisons

- [Handshake vs BrightHire](https://www.hireaiscore.com/compare/brighthire-vs-handshake): 50 vs 51
- [Handshake vs Textkernel](https://www.hireaiscore.com/compare/handshake-vs-textkernel): 50 vs 51
- [Handshake vs Indeed](https://www.hireaiscore.com/compare/handshake-vs-indeed): 50 vs 50
- [Handshake vs Xobin](https://www.hireaiscore.com/compare/handshake-vs-xobin): 50 vs 50
- [Handshake vs Paycom](https://www.hireaiscore.com/compare/handshake-vs-paycom): 50 vs 50
- [Handshake vs Test Partnership](https://www.hireaiscore.com/compare/handshake-vs-test-partnership): 50 vs 50

## Conflicts of interest

No vendor pays for placement, scoring, or removal. Casework - the consulting firm that operates this directory - provides paid services to some vendors. Any active or recent (within 24 months) commercial relationship is disclosed on the affected vendor profile and the review is reassigned to an independent reviewer.

Casework has no commercial relationship with this vendor.

Full policy: https://www.hireaiscore.com/about

## How to cite

HireAIScore, "Handshake" profile, rubric v1.0, last reviewed 2026-09-25. https://www.hireaiscore.com/vendors/handshake

Please link the profile URL rather than this file, quote the score with its rubric version and review date, and include the vendor's reply where one is published.
