# Jack & Jill: HireAIScore fact sheet

URL: https://www.hireaiscore.com/vendors/jack-and-jill
Fact sheet: https://www.hireaiscore.com/vendors/jack-and-jill/facts.md
Last reviewed: 2026-09-25
Rubric: v1.0 (https://www.hireaiscore.com/methodology)

> HireAIScore rates Jack & Jill 49 out of 100 (grade F, Substantial gaps) under rubric v1.0, last reviewed September 25, 2026. Jack & Jill ranks 31 of 86 vendors rated in Candidate sourcing AI, against a category average of 46. That score is drawn from 36 evidence items across 7 rubric criteria - 31 with a cited source, 5 recording that nothing was located.

This file is the text of the profile at the URL above, for AI assistants and other software. Scores are an editorial assessment of public evidence against a published rubric. They are not legal advice, a certification, or a statement that a product is or is not compliant.

## Score

- Overall: 49/100, grade F (Substantial gaps)
- Rank: 31 of 86 in Candidate sourcing AI (category average 46)

## Criterion scores and evidence

### Article 11 Technical Documentation: 44/100 (weight 20%)

- Documentation (captured 2026-09-25): The CEO's blog (5 July 2026) describes Jill's per-role pipeline of LLM 'gates', each with chosen candidate fields, a tiered-criteria prompt, a structured output and a composite filter, run as one LLM call per candidate, with protected characteristics stripped first and prompts readable in the brief page. Source: https://www.jackandjill.ai/blog/ai-sourcing-is-broken-by-design
- Documentation (captured 2026-09-25): The docs say the hiring brief holds the evaluation criteria every candidate is scored on, signals and anti-signals, and Jill's sourcing strategy and ranking logic, with a version history that can be restored. Source: https://www.jackandjill.ai/docs/hiring-brief
- Documentation (captured 2026-09-25): Warden's audit report gives the only third-party system description: inputs are job criteria and the candidate résumé, and the output is a match score. Source: https://trust.warden-ai.com/jackandjill/ai-candidate-matching/nyc
- Searched, not found (captured 2026-09-25): No model card, AI policy or principles page, validation study for the match percentage, EU AI Act technical documentation or ISO 42001 claim was found in the docs hub, legal pages, llms.txt, llms-full.txt or the blog posts in the sitemap, and /security, /trust, /ai-policy and /responsible-ai all return 404.

### Bias Audit Transparency: 62/100 (weight 18%)

- Audit report (captured 2026-09-25): Warden AI's public dashboard for Jack & Jill's AI Candidate Matching shows one evaluation, dated 8 January 2026 (22,218 test samples, 15 protected categories plus sex by race, 102 Clear results), although it labels the audit frequency 'Monthly'. Source: https://trust.warden-ai.com/jackandjill/ai-candidate-matching
- Audit report (captured 2026-09-25): The NYC LL 144 report (8 January 2026) was run on Warden's own test profiles 'due to a lack of access to historical data' and shows sex impact ratios of 1.00 and 0.98, race ratios of 0.97 to 1.00, and a lowest intersectional ratio of 0.93 (Asian men). Source: https://trust.warden-ai.com/jackandjill/ai-candidate-matching/nyc
- Audit report (captured 2026-09-25): The EU AI Act bias report (same date, test data) adds counterfactual consistency testing (100% for women, 99.36% for men) and says it is not evidence of full EU AI Act compliance. Source: https://trust.warden-ai.com/jackandjill/ai-candidate-matching/eu-ai-act
- Documentation (captured 2026-09-25): Warden's Assured Directory lists Jack & Jill's AI Candidate Matching as assured from 17 December 2025. Source: https://www.warden-ai.com/warden-assured-directory
- Public statement (captured 2026-09-25): The site footer's 'Bias Report' link leads to a downloadable marketing guide ('The 2026 guide to bias in AI for recruitment') with no audit results, auditor or dates, so it is not credited as an audit. Source: https://www.jackandjill.ai/jill/bias
- Public statement (captured 2026-09-25): The CEO's July 2026 blog says the company runs 'regular audits on our debiasing' and publishes its methodology at /jill/bias, which is the marketing guide page, not the Warden audit. Source: https://www.jackandjill.ai/blog/ai-sourcing-is-broken-by-design

### FRIA Support: 28/100 (weight 15%)

- Searched, not found (captured 2026-09-25): No FRIA template, EU AI Act instructions for use or deployer-obligation guidance appears in the 13-guide docs hub, the Platform Terms, the Data Sharing Agreement, the privacy policy, llms.txt or the blog.
- Audit report (captured 2026-09-25): Warden's EU AI Act bias report is the only EU-specific material; it gives deployers bias-test results and a generic list of provider and deployer duties, not an impact-assessment template. Source: https://trust.warden-ai.com/jackandjill/ai-candidate-matching/eu-ai-act

### Data Governance Disclosure: 48/100 (weight 15%)

- Documentation (captured 2026-09-25): The privacy policy (dated 10 August 2026) relies on contract and legitimate interests for matching (consent only for special-category data), says Jack's call recordings and transcripts are never shared with employers, rules out biometric voiceprints and third-party model training, and keeps legally required data for at most two years after a deletion request. Source: https://www.jackandjill.ai/privacy
- Documentation (captured 2026-09-25): The same policy says public professional profiles from LinkedIn and similar sources are collected under legitimate interests and scored by AI for the Sourcing feature, with a right to object but no described way of notifying those non-users. Source: https://www.jackandjill.ai/privacy
- Documentation (captured 2026-09-25): The CEO's blog says all candidate context is stripped of protected characteristics before any matching gate runs, but no list of stripped fields is published. Source: https://www.jackandjill.ai/blog/ai-sourcing-is-broken-by-design
- Documentation (captured 2026-09-25): Warden's case study says Jack & Jill redacts candidate information before matching to reduce proxy bias. Source: https://www.warden-ai.com/case-studies/jack-jill-stress-tests-agentic-ai-for-bias-risk
- Documentation (captured 2026-09-25): The Data Sharing Agreement (effective 28 January 2026) makes Jack & Jill and each hirer independent controllers, incorporates the UK Addendum for restricted transfers, and lists the job-seeker data categories shared with hirers. Source: https://www.jackandjill.ai/terms#data-sharing-agreement
- Documentation (captured 2026-09-25): The Platform Terms name OpenAI, Anthropic, Google and ElevenLabs as model providers and allow AI models to be trained on customer information in anonymised, aggregated form. Source: https://www.jackandjill.ai/terms#platform-terms
- Public statement (captured 2026-09-25): The app FAQ says a candidate's profile, professional details and contact information are 'automatically shared' with matching employers by default unless the candidate opts out, which contradicts the privacy policy's opt-in visibility and mutual-consent contact sharing. Source: https://app.jackandjill.ai/faq
- Searched, not found (captured 2026-09-25): No SOC 2, ISO 27001 or other security certification, trust center, subprocessor list or DPIA summary was found: trust.jackandjill.ai, security.jackandjill.ai and jackandjill.safebase.io do not resolve, trust.drata.com/jackandjill returns 404, and app.vanta.com/jackandjill/trust redirects to a login page.

### Human Oversight Design: 58/100 (weight 12%)

- Documentation (captured 2026-09-25): Hiring teams define evaluation criteria with Jill, can open any candidate to see their score on every criterion alongside experience and education, and decide whether to shortlist or pass. Source: https://www.jackandjill.ai/docs/search-and-candidate-discovery
- Documentation (captured 2026-09-25): The getting-started guide says Jill explains why she picked each candidate and adds 'small flags or things to verify'. Source: https://www.jackandjill.ai/docs/getting-started
- Documentation (captured 2026-09-25): The Platform Terms tell hirers not to rely on any Jill suggestion 'without prior human intervention, review and approval' by a qualified team member, and make the hirer responsible for every decision to engage a candidate. Source: https://www.jackandjill.ai/terms#platform-terms
- Documentation (captured 2026-09-25): The CEO's blog says early gates cut candidates on location, visa and function before later gates judge subtler traits, and that every gate prompt is readable in the brief page, but nothing documented lets the hiring team review the candidates the gates exclude. Source: https://www.jackandjill.ai/blog/ai-sourcing-is-broken-by-design
- Documentation (captured 2026-09-25): The docs say Jill shortlists the best candidates each day and that if a team consistently passes on a certain academic or professional background 'she'll deprioritise similar profiles'. Source: https://www.jackandjill.ai/docs/pipeline-management
- Documentation (captured 2026-09-25): The privacy policy says Jack & Jill uses automated decision-making for matchmaking and invites anyone who wants a decision reviewed by a human to email legal@jackandjill.ai. Source: https://www.jackandjill.ai/privacy
- Documentation (captured 2026-09-25): A 'How selective Jill should be' setting lets hirers move her bar 'from broader to only the clearest matches', and 'Reset search approach' rebuilds the search from the candidates the hirer said yes to. Source: https://www.jackandjill.ai/docs/working-with-jill
- Documentation (captured 2026-09-25): Introductions are consent-based: the candidate must accept through Jack before any contact details are shared. Source: https://www.jackandjill.ai/docs/introductions

### Post-Market Monitoring: 48/100 (weight 12%)

- Documentation (captured 2026-09-25): An incident.io status page that the site does not link tracks five components (the website plus Jill's and Jack's web apps and emails) and lists six incidents from 2 July to 21 September 2026 with timestamped updates but no postmortems. Source: https://status.jackandjill.ai/history
- Documentation (captured 2026-09-25): A security.txt file names security@jackandjill.ai as the security contact, valid to 10 February 2027. Source: https://www.jackandjill.ai/.well-known/security.txt
- Audit report (captured 2026-09-25): Warden's dashboard advertises continuous bias auditing and post-market monitoring on a monthly cycle, but the only evaluation it publishes is dated 8 January 2026. Source: https://trust.warden-ai.com/jackandjill/ai-candidate-matching
- Searched, not found (captured 2026-09-25): No public changelog, model or prompt update log, or AI-incident channel was found (/changelog, /updates and /release-notes return 404), and the privacy policy's claim of regular outcome audits has no published results beyond the January 2026 Warden audit.

### Customer Documentation: 56/100 (weight 8%)

- Documentation (captured 2026-09-25): A public docs hub has 13 guides covering the hiring brief, search and candidate discovery, introductions, pipeline management, role configuration, team permissions and Ashby, custom-ATS and Slack integrations. Source: https://www.jackandjill.ai/docs
- Documentation (captured 2026-09-25): Hirer-facing Platform Terms (effective 1 July 2026) explain how Jill works, fees, the AI subcontractors used and the hirer's duty of human review before acting on Jill's suggestions. Source: https://www.jackandjill.ai/terms#platform-terms
- Documentation (captured 2026-09-25): A Data Sharing Agreement sets out controller roles, international transfer terms and the categories of job-seeker data shared with hirers. Source: https://www.jackandjill.ai/terms#data-sharing-agreement
- Searched, not found (captured 2026-09-25): No customer guidance on NYC LL 144 candidate notices, Illinois HB 3773 notices, Colorado disclosures or EU AI Act deployer duties was found in the docs hub, legal pages, FAQ, llms.txt or blog.

## Company facts

- Website: https://www.jackandjill.ai
- Legal name: Tinker Tailor Talent Limited
- Founded: 2025
- Headquarters: United Kingdom (GB)
- Pricing tier: Mid
- Market side: Employer-side (AEDT)
- Categories: Candidate sourcing AI, Screening AI
- Description: Jack & Jill is a London AI recruiting marketplace. Its free career agent, Jack, interviews and profiles candidates, and its employer-side AI recruiter, Jill, turns a role brief into a scoring rubric, ranks candidates from Jack's network (and optionally public profiles) with a percentage match, and arranges introductions only when both sides agree.

These are company details, not findings, and carry no weight in the score.

## Head-to-head comparisons

- [Jack & Jill vs Indeed](https://www.hireaiscore.com/compare/indeed-vs-jack-and-jill): 49 vs 50
- [Jack & Jill vs SeekOut](https://www.hireaiscore.com/compare/jack-and-jill-vs-seekout): 49 vs 50
- [Jack & Jill vs Handshake](https://www.hireaiscore.com/compare/handshake-vs-jack-and-jill): 49 vs 50
- [Jack & Jill vs Stepstone](https://www.hireaiscore.com/compare/jack-and-jill-vs-stepstone): 49 vs 49
- [Jack & Jill vs Lever](https://www.hireaiscore.com/compare/jack-and-jill-vs-lever): 49 vs 49
- [Jack & Jill vs Oracle Recruiting](https://www.hireaiscore.com/compare/jack-and-jill-vs-oracle-recruiting): 49 vs 49

## Conflicts of interest

No vendor pays for placement, scoring, or removal. Casework - the consulting firm that operates this directory - provides paid services to some vendors. Any active or recent (within 24 months) commercial relationship is disclosed on the affected vendor profile and the review is reassigned to an independent reviewer.

Casework has no commercial relationship with this vendor.

Full policy: https://www.hireaiscore.com/about

## How to cite

HireAIScore, "Jack & Jill" profile, rubric v1.0, last reviewed 2026-09-25. https://www.hireaiscore.com/vendors/jack-and-jill

Please link the profile URL rather than this file, quote the score with its rubric version and review date, and include the vendor's reply where one is published.
