# SmartRecruiters: HireAIScore fact sheet

URL: https://www.hireaiscore.com/vendors/smartrecruiters
Fact sheet: https://www.hireaiscore.com/vendors/smartrecruiters/facts.md
Last reviewed: 2026-11-14
Rubric: v1.0 (https://www.hireaiscore.com/methodology)

> HireAIScore rates SmartRecruiters 62 out of 100 (grade D, Concerning) under rubric v1.0, last reviewed November 14, 2026. SmartRecruiters ranks 4 of 77 vendors rated in ATS-integrated AI, against a category average of 47. That score is drawn from 13 evidence items across 7 rubric criteria - 11 with a cited source, 2 recording that nothing was located.

This file is the text of the profile at the URL above, for AI assistants and other software. Scores are an editorial assessment of public evidence against a published rubric. They are not legal advice, a certification, or a statement that a product is or is not compliant.

## Score

- Overall: 62/100, grade D (Concerning)
- Rank: 4 of 77 in ATS-integrated AI (category average 47)

## Criterion scores and evidence

### Article 11 Technical Documentation: 70/100 (weight 20%)

- Documentation (captured 2026-06-07): The public Artificial Intelligence Addendum documents the AI feature set (Winston Chat, Match, Screen, Companion), the provider/deployer split, training-data handling, and the limits of automated decisioning. Source: https://www.smartrecruiters.com/legal/artificial-intelligence-addendum/
- Public statement (captured 2026-06-07): SmartRecruiters describes a 'compliance by design' product process that maps platform features against EU AI Act risk levels and data-governance requirements. Source: https://assets.smartrecruiters.com/blog/the-impact-of-the-eu-ai-act-on-talent-acquisition-an-experts-perspective/

### Bias Audit Transparency: 78/100 (weight 18%)

- Audit report (captured 2026-06-07): Publicly downloadable NYC LL144 bias audit of SmartAssistant by independent auditor ConductorAI (produced 07/11/2023) covering 4,196,161 candidates across multiple employers, with sex, race and intersectional impact ratios all at or above 0.82. Source: https://nyc-144-audits.s3.amazonaws.com/smartrecruiters-inc.pdf

### FRIA Support: 45/100 (weight 15%)

- Documentation (captured 2026-06-07): The AI Addendum assigns SmartRecruiters the EU AI Act 'Provider' role and the customer the 'Deployer' role responsible for compliance with applicable AI laws, and states AI Features are 'not designed to replace human oversight.' Source: https://www.smartrecruiters.com/legal/artificial-intelligence-addendum/
- Searched, not found (captured 2026-06-07): No EU AI Act Article 27 Fundamental Rights Impact Assessment template or deployer FRIA checklist was found on the public site, the legal pages, the EU AI Act article, or the public Trust Center index.

### Data Governance Disclosure: 62/100 (weight 15%)

- Audit report (captured 2026-06-07): SOC 2 Type II clean opinion by Sensiba San Filippo covering security, availability, processing integrity, confidentiality and privacy, alongside stated ISO 27001 certification and GDPR/CCPA support. Source: https://www.smartrecruiters.com/news/soc-2-type-ii-2023/
- Documentation (captured 2026-06-07): Public subprocessor list discloses third parties processing customer and candidate data. Source: https://www.smartrecruiters.com/legal/subprocessors

### Human Oversight Design: 62/100 (weight 12%)

- Public statement (captured 2026-06-07): Winston Match presents candidate evaluations on a four-star scale 'with explainability included,' and the AI Control Center gives organizations 'precise visibility and control over what Winston sees, learns, and acts on' with full auditability. Source: https://www.smartrecruiters.com/news/smartrecruiters-unveils-ai-powered-platform-that-ends-the-ats-era/
- Documentation (captured 2026-06-07): The AI Addendum states AI Features 'do not independently evaluate, score, or rank candidates' as a sole basis for decisions and 'are not designed to replace human oversight,' placing the human in control. Source: https://www.smartrecruiters.com/legal/artificial-intelligence-addendum/

### Post-Market Monitoring: 48/100 (weight 12%)

- Audit report (captured 2026-06-07): SOC 2 Type II continuous-controls reporting demonstrates an ongoing monitoring and security-attestation cadence. Source: https://www.smartrecruiters.com/news/soc-2-type-ii-2023/
- Searched, not found (captured 2026-06-07): No public AI model-update changelog or continuous bias/fairness monitoring dashboard was found on the product pages or the public Trust Center index.

### Customer Documentation: 63/100 (weight 8%)

- Documentation (captured 2026-06-07): Public AI Addendum gives customers contractual guidance on AI feature scope, provider/deployer roles, training-data use and oversight expectations. Source: https://www.smartrecruiters.com/legal/artificial-intelligence-addendum/
- Public statement (captured 2026-06-07): Public expert article guides customers on EU AI Act cataloguing, risk-level mapping and data governance for talent acquisition. Source: https://assets.smartrecruiters.com/blog/the-impact-of-the-eu-ai-act-on-talent-acquisition-an-experts-perspective/

## Company facts

- Website: https://www.smartrecruiters.com/
- Legal name: SmartRecruiters, Inc.
- Founded: 2010
- Headquarters: United States (US)
- Pricing tier: Enterprise
- Market side: Employer-side (AEDT)
- Categories: ATS-integrated AI, Screening AI, Candidate sourcing AI
- Description: SmartRecruiters is an enterprise applicant tracking system and talent acquisition suite whose AI layer (the Winston assistant plus SmartAssistant/Winston Match) screens, ranks, and matches candidates to requisitions to support recruiter decisions.

These are company details, not findings, and carry no weight in the score.

## Head-to-head comparisons

- [SmartRecruiters vs Eightfold AI](https://www.hireaiscore.com/compare/eightfold-ai-vs-smartrecruiters): 62 vs 67
- [SmartRecruiters vs Greenhouse](https://www.hireaiscore.com/compare/greenhouse-vs-smartrecruiters): 62 vs 67
- [SmartRecruiters vs PageUp](https://www.hireaiscore.com/compare/pageup-vs-smartrecruiters): 62 vs 64
- [SmartRecruiters vs Alva Labs](https://www.hireaiscore.com/compare/alva-labs-vs-smartrecruiters): 62 vs 61
- [SmartRecruiters vs Workday Recruiting AI](https://www.hireaiscore.com/compare/smartrecruiters-vs-workday-recruiting-ai): 62 vs 59
- [SmartRecruiters vs HiredScore](https://www.hireaiscore.com/compare/hiredscore-vs-smartrecruiters): 62 vs 58

## Conflicts of interest

No vendor pays for placement, scoring, or removal. Casework - the consulting firm that operates this directory - provides paid services to some vendors. Any active or recent (within 24 months) commercial relationship is disclosed on the affected vendor profile and the review is reassigned to an independent reviewer.

Casework has no commercial relationship with this vendor.

Full policy: https://www.hireaiscore.com/about

## How to cite

HireAIScore, "SmartRecruiters" profile, rubric v1.0, last reviewed 2026-11-14. https://www.hireaiscore.com/vendors/smartrecruiters

Please link the profile URL rather than this file, quote the score with its rubric version and review date, and include the vendor's reply where one is published.
